Biological Labs or Biological Weapons Labs?

Tiempo de lectura: 5 minutos

Te puede interesar

Is there a clear distinction between biological labs and biological weapons labs? Here is how the paper, written by a student at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, discusses the issue:

“The argument is not strange, as it refers to the thin line scientists walk, who can slip (and very occasionally have) from useful biological countermeasures to deceptive biological weapons. The creation of the latter, while claiming the former, is known as dual-use research. In the 1950s, scientists were accused of this behavior when they developed a new version of the polio virus, used to create the polio vaccine. Critics argued that releasing this virus could decimate an unprepared population, while scientists sought to assure that it was only for the beneficial cause of a miracle treatment.”

In 2002, after the September 11 attacks and the anthrax letters, the United States allocated money to build two maximum-containment biology labs. Called biosafety level 4 (BSL-4) facilities, these labs were built to research new vaccines, diagnostics and treatments for emerging infectious diseases and potential biological weapons, and to contribute to the nation’s biodefense. These labs were not the first dramatic reaction to the threat of biological warfare and are, in fact, a product of the country’s long, controversial history with biological weapons.

READ ALSO: U.S. Gave Millions to a Chinese Hospital Linked to Forced Organ Harvesting

This discussion was outlined in a thesis written in 2013 about a BSL-4 facility being considered for construction in the heart of Boston. These labs can be controversial even when governments are fully transparent, and they will certainly be controversial when governments are secretive, because even though they are designed and intended for the public good, these labs can easily be converted to nefarious, dual-use purposes.

It is what many of us believe about the Wuhan Institute of Virology in China, where COVID-19 could have originated and leaked. The Wuhan lab likely carried out some scientific research, but part of the facility was also under the control of the People’s Liberation Army (PLA), conducting biological weapons research.

The bottom line is that biomedical research, as noted above, can provide enormous benefits, but it can also produce horrible pathogens that can kill millions of people. How do you tell the difference when you suspect a country may be developing biological weapons and you want to be able to prevent them from succeeding? That is the exact dilemma the world finds itself in today.

The debate over biolabs and biological weapons became such a hot topic that it became part of what could be called the propaganda war between Russia, China and the United States. The issue is so potent that U.S. Senator Marco Rubio, vice chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee, rightly warned that Russia could be preparing a pretext for a “false flag” attack, after Russia recently alleged that Ukraine worked with the U.S. on a secret biological weapons program.

Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov claimed that one of the reasons Russia needed to invade Ukraine was the dangerous biological labs located in the country with possible stockpiles of biological weapons. It is not the first time Russia has made this claim. It made the same accusation about a lab in the Republic of Georgia in 2018. Likewise, the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) pointed to the U.S. Army’s biomedical research facility at Fort Detrick, in Maryland, and claimed it was a potential source of the COVID-19 virus.

For its part, the United States highlighted the work done on coronaviruses at the Wuhan Institute of Virology as one of the possible sources of the COVID-19 virus. This admission led to intense debate over whether the virus was engineered or developed naturally.

It is ironic that the war in Ukraine led the Chinese government, through its Foreign Ministry, to call for clarification of what U.S. biolabs do and for multilateral inspections to be allowed. The Chinese communist government described the work at these facilities as biological militarization. It is also ironic because, in the case of COVID-19, the Chinese Communist Party government restricted access to the Wuhan lab, destroyed information and delayed sharing information about the virus with the global community. The Wuhan lab was never opened to an independent, multilateral inspection team even though the world experienced more than six million deaths from COVID-19.

Meanwhile, the Chinese Communist Party was clear about its own intentions to develop and potentially use biological weapons. Colonel Guo Ji-wei and other PLA scientific researchers promoted biological weapons and “biologically based” warfare in Chinese military journals. In “The Unnatural Origin of SARS and New Species of Man-Made Viruses as Genetic Bioweapons”, Chinese military scientists even stated that World War III will be fought with biological weapons.

As for the biolabs in Ukraine, the United States has its own explanations. After the fall of the Soviet Union, according to PolitiFact, the U.S. Department of Defense’s Cooperative Threat Reduction Program provided technical support to public health labs in Ukraine similar to our Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). The labs are run by the host countries, contrary to what is claimed, and the people quoted by PolitiFact say the accusations are pure Russian and Chinese propaganda with no basis.

In fact, the Biden administration was so unconcerned by these claims that Victoria Nuland, Under Secretary of State for Political Affairs, gave an awkward answer to a simple question about the program in testimony before the Senate. Her answer was immediately seized upon by Russian state-controlled Russia Today and by Glenn Greenwald, who is a prominent critic of support for Ukraine.

With COVID-19, the Wuhan lab, a hot war in Europe and the growing debate over biological weapons, whether propaganda or with some elements of truth, the world’s major powers must be more transparent and direct when it comes to biomedical research. Current medical advances are revolutionizing health treatments within reach of everyone. However, one simple misstep or miscalculation could subject the world to a terrifying pandemic that could create far greater damage than the COVID-19 virus or the current war in Ukraine. Now is the time for world leaders to respond to this emerging threat with greater transparency. Tomorrow may be too late.

This article was originally published in Gatestone on March 10, 2022

Author: Pete Hoekstra

Artículo previo
Reflections on the War in Ukraine: A Strategic Opportunity for China
Siguiente artículo
The Golden Dragon China Index Plunges on the Stock Market

Artículos Relacionados