energética china

Energy Crisis in China: How Does It Affect Spain?

Tiempo de lectura: 4 minutos

Te puede interesar

In parallel with the unstoppable rise in electricity prices we have been experiencing across Europe for months, China is going through a similar situation that is causing widespread blackouts and a major halt in industrial production. Are the two facts related, and how can the Chinese energy crisis affect Spain? In this article we will address both questions.

In reality, the similarity between the European and the Chinese cases lies in their external dependence on fossil energy sources (oil, natural gas, coal, etc.) and in the regulatory steps being taken to decarbonize their economies. The most widespread argument among public opinion to justify abandoning fossil fuels is to reduce the increase in CO2 emissions into the atmosphere that they generate, which aggravate the effect of so-called “climate change,” with terrible consequences in the medium and long term according to the United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC).

To a lesser extent, their harmful effect on air quality, mainly in cities (heating, combustion vehicles, nearby industry, etc.), is also discussed. It is not the aim of this article to assess how accurate these predictions are, although there is no doubt that CO2 emissions affect the planet’s global temperature and that the use of fossil fuels negatively impacts air quality. One of the points we want to highlight is the other two reasons that explain this decarbonization process and that many media outlets are overlooking: energy independence from abroad and energy efficiency.

READ ALSO: Repeat After Me, Mr. Casado: China Is a Dictatorship

Energy independence from abroad has very important geopolitical implications. For example, in Spain approximately 30% of a manufacturing company’s costs are due to energy, and if those prices depend directly or indirectly on foreign countries (Russia, Saudi Arabia, etc.), the course of the economy and its competitiveness are compromised by external causes. That is why Europe and China, although at different speeds, are promoting the decarbonization of their economies and investing in progressive energy and geopolitical independence.

On the other hand, energy efficiency implies an increase in competitiveness in the medium to long term. But what is energy efficiency? In the electricity sector, it is measured as the amount of primary energy (gas, coal, wind, sun or rain) needed to generate 1 MWh of electricity. In the case of vehicles, it is measured as the amount of fuel (liters of gasoline, diesel or kWh of electricity) needed to move them 1 km. Coal-fired power plants, even new-generation ones, have worse energy efficiency than the other generation sources. Combined-cycle gas plants are better than coal plants but inferior to nuclear, hydroelectric and of course wind and solar plants (where the natural resource, although intermittent, has no cost).

One can then ask why the US depends so heavily on natural gas, or why China still generates 60% of its electricity with coal if that generation is less efficient. The explanation lies in the cost of fuel. In thermal plants (coal or gas), 80% of generation costs depend on the fuel price, which is why countries with their own deposits are reluctant to abandon those generation sources, even though they are much less energy-efficient. They are less efficient in energy terms, but more efficient in economic terms.

So why is China gradually abandoning coal? On the one hand, because in international markets sustainability and environmental impact criteria are increasingly important, and if it wants to maintain its worldwide leadership in manufacturing, it is strategic to take steps in that direction. On the other hand, the quality of domestic coal is not always the best and the mining required represents an extra cost. For China, generating from coal is not so cheap compared with renewables (zero cost of wind or sun), which is why it is being gradually abandoned. In addition, major investments in renewables in the immense Chinese domestic “market” allow its energy companies to position themselves as world leaders, facilitating investments and purchases abroad such as that of China Three Gorges Corporation in Portugal.

However, the main problem with this energy transition is that, without the availability of large energy storage systems (whether batteries or large water reservoirs in pumped-storage hydro systems) until at least the next decade, complete independence from fossil sources is not possible, and depending on each country’s market design, price increases affect the electricity bill differently. Therefore, returning to the current situation, the very significant rise in international natural gas and coal markets has hit importing regions such as Europe or China especially hard. Specifically, in China the decline in domestic coal production (due to the decarbonization process) and the trade war with Australia (which prevents it from importing coal from that country) have reduced generation capacity, while the global economic reactivation (increasing the output of its factories) and an especially hot summer across Asia have increased demand for electricity.

This “perfect storm” has forced the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) to make a very specific decision: not to raise electricity prices, forcing producers not to operate so as not to lose money. Moreover, the CCP is actively rationing demand by requiring electricity-intensive companies to cease operating on certain days and at peak hours. The real problem with this stance will come if the international situation persists for months because, as the economist Juan Ramón Rallo very accurately states, lower Chinese production means greater disruption of global value chains; this, plus a shortage of products in a context of strong demand, and therefore more domestic inflation, will lead us to an interest rate rise that will restrict our domestic spending even before we have recovered from the effects of the pandemic.

In upcoming articles we will analyze the causes of these price rises, their possible duration and the impact that CCP policies may have on the international economy. There is a lot of talk about Evergrande but, for Spain, this situation has a much greater direct impact in the short to medium term.

Artículo previo
Judgment Day Arrives for Evergrande: Creditors Demand “Immediate” Payment
Siguiente artículo
“China Must Pay the Coronavirus Bill,” Say Victims and Those Affected in Spain

Artículos Relacionados