China’s Zero-COVID Strategy: Part II

Tiempo de lectura: 21 minutos

Te puede interesar

No results found.

What China’s ‘Zero COVID’ Policy Hides: Part I

The CCP’s “Soft Weapons” to Control Citizens

Over the past two years, the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) has demonstrated a strict “zero-COVID” strategy. It implemented complete lockdowns and quarantines with repeated mandatory COVID tests. This total lockdown strategy created many humanitarian crises in China, as recently exemplified in Shanghai. (1)

However, for policymakers and social studies researchers, a question is worth asking: How could the CCP enact such a policy when the free world could not?

The secret to implementing the “zero-COVID” approach is the CCP’s total control over the Chinese population. The virus is invisible and does not take orders from the authorities, so the CCP chooses to focus on what it can control: the people of China. Over the past decades, the CCP has built a massive, systematic, prison-like infrastructure to control the Chinese people, and this system was fully used and expanded even further during the pandemic.

One must also ask why the CCP clings to the “zero-COVID” approach rather than the alternative, coexisting with the virus, which creates far fewer humanitarian disasters. The answer is that the CCP has an innate fear of COVID. This fear is not motivated by concern for the Chinese people or a desire to spare them suffering. Rather, the virus represents a threat to the CCP’s hold on power. In fact, many Chinese are fed up with the CCP’s tyrannies and do not tolerate the regime’s mistakes much. An explosion of COVID-related deaths could trigger a wave of public protests, shaking the CCP’s hold on power, so the CCP will do everything possible to suppress the virus in China.

However, when it comes to controlling the spread of the virus, the practicality and effectiveness of the CCP’s lockdowns are questionable, especially considering how highly transmissible the Omicron variant is. That said, this article will not discuss the merits or flaws of the lockdown approach from an epidemiological perspective. Instead, we will take a sociological view of the CCP’s population control mechanisms.

The first part of this series analyzed the “hard weapons” employed by the CCP regime to control and monitor the population. These include the regime’s power at all levels of state and local governments, the army and the police, as well as its unique mechanisms such as city administrators and grid managers.

This article, the second part of the series on “zero-COVID,” analyzes the CCP’s “soft weapons”: state media, online censors, web commentators tasked with creating fake news, and high-tech solutions, such as the mandatory “Health Code” smartphone app. Together, these tools turn the country into something resembling a huge prison, forcing the “cooperation” of the Chinese people.

IV. The CCP’s “Soft Weapons”

IV – A. The CCP’s “Pen”

The CCP controls all media in China. The party’s Central Propaganda Department sets the tone for information and publications, while the National Radio and Television Administration oversees the radio, television, film and publishing industries. To control the Internet, the CCP created a special cyberspace administration. That office has two titles: the “CCP Office of the Central Cyberspace Affairs Commission” and the “State Internet Information Office” (SIIO). These two affiliations of one entity, one reporting to the CCP Central Committee and the other to the State Council (the government), guarantee the party’s control over the Internet and legitimize its administrative power.

China’s major media outlets, such as the People’s Daily, the Xinhua News Agency and China Central Television (CCTV), are controlled by the CCP. CCP Party Committees or local governments also own some media companies. There is no purely private media outlet in China. Internet and social media companies, such as WeChat or Weibo, are privately owned, but they have to follow the CCP’s strict guidelines and create their own censorship teams to proactively delete posts that contradict the tone set by the CCP’s propaganda office.

While Westerners enjoy freedom of speech, the Chinese people can only hear one voice: that of the CCP. Any story or comment that could have a negative effect on the “glorious” image of the CCP is “harmonized” [wiped clean]. When the media report, they focus on the positive aspects of the story to glorify the CCP, downplaying the negative side or denouncing undesirable news (for example, protests or mass incidents) as rumors.

Sometimes the media cooperate directly with other government entities to fabricate news about false events in order to deceive the public. This can be used to stir up public animosity against a group or idea that is a target of the CCP. For example, the staged self-immolation in Tiananmen Square was used to incite hatred against Falun Gong, a spiritual practice in the Buddhist tradition that upholds the core principles of truthfulness, compassion and tolerance. On January 23, 2001, five people posing as Falun Gong practitioners set themselves on fire in Tiananmen Square. CCTV immediately broadcast the video to the public, making many Chinese believe that Falun Gong promotes suicide, and inciting hatred against Falun Gong practitioners. A careful analysis revealed that the incident was staged: it was a collaboration between the police and the CCTV video crew.

The video shows police and firefighters arriving with fire extinguishers seconds after the immolation began, yet on a normal day there was not a single fire extinguisher in sight in Tiananmen Square. The video also shows many close-ups, indicating that the cameramen were prepared for the event, positioned right in front of the actors who set themselves on fire. Moreover, those actors were not even Falun Gong practitioners. A Washington Post reporter visited the village of Liu Chunling, who died during the incident. In interviews with Liu’s neighbors, the reporter learned that “none had seen her practice Falun Gong.” {2} In fact, Falun Gong is against suicide.

The background to the staged self-immolation is that the then-CCP head, Jiang Zemin, launched a persecution of Falun Gong on July 20, 1999, with the aim of eliminating Falun Gong within three months. This was unsuccessful, as by the end of 2000, millions of people were still practicing Falun Gong (even though tens of thousands of practitioners had been imprisoned). The failure of the regime’s persecution efforts is what motivated the police to collaborate with CCTV to fabricate the self-immolation incident, to make the Chinese people hate and fight Falun Gong practitioners.

Throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, CCTV and other major Chinese media did everything possible to convey the CCP’s messages to the Chinese people. The initial strategy for dealing with the COVID outbreak in Wuhan was to hide the information; in the early days, the media focused on helping the Chinese authorities attack the whistleblowers Dr. Li Wenliang and Dr. Ai Fen, saying they were spreading rumors.

Later, 25 hours after the initial lockdown of Wuhan, an article began circulating online in China and in overseas Chinese media. This article told the story of the villagers of Eyam who, during the Great Plague of London (1665-1666), were affected by the virus and decided to isolate themselves to save others from it. Although all the villagers perished from the plague, the result of their decision to isolate was that the bubonic plague was prevented from entering Scotland. The online story praised the villagers of Eyam for being willing to sacrifice themselves for the benefit of others. {3}

Obviously, the article had a hidden, well-timed agenda: to encourage the Chinese, especially those locked down in Wuhan, to follow the example of the villagers of Eyam, sacrificing themselves to contain the spread of COVID-19. This article was widely distributed among major Chinese newspapers and social media, such as Weibo and WeChat. Strangely, this great “positive energy” article was from a mysterious author called “Walking Among Strange Paths.” It is unknown what other works the author published or where he initially published this Eyam Village article.

During the initial lockdown of Wuhan, this article may have inspired the city’s residents, as well as the 346 medical teams and 42,000 medical staff members from 29 provinces and cities that the CCP ordered to go to Wuhan as volunteers. Soon after the authorities acknowledged the pandemic, Chinese media were busy reporting on how great these volunteers were and how brave they were under the great leadership of the CCP.

IV – B. The CCP’s Cyber Control

To control cyberspace, the CCP employs the cyber police, web commentators and the youth web army. These forces make it possible to control the web both inside and, to some extent, outside China.

Beijing’s cyber police are made up of personnel from the Ministry of State Security and the Ministry of Public Security. This police force operates a “Golden Shield” system, which automatically filters the Internet, blocking Chinese people from information the CCP does not want them to access. The Cyber Police also monitor all cyber activities of Chinese citizens, both inside China and abroad. They can quickly delete any unwanted post in Chinese cyberspace and trace content on the web back to the person who originally posted it.

For example, a Weibo user posted an article about how people had different opinions from the authorities’ guidelines on garbage separation and classification. As a result, police harassed him multiple times starting the next day. {4}

The long arm of the CCP’s cyber police even reaches outside China. For example, a Chinese student who studied in Canada was harassed after registering a Twitter account with a fake name and female gender. After he retweeted three tweets from others, which referred to the CCP’s corruption and human rights violations, the Chinese cyber police called and threatened him by phone. The police also harassed his parents in China. {5}

There are nearly two million web commentators spread throughout the country. For example, at Fudan University in Shanghai alone there are more than 2,000 web commentators. These web commentators are sometimes called members of the “50 Cent Party (五毛党)” because in the past they were paid 50 cents for each post they published supporting the CCP’s “main theme.” Today, the reward system for them is more complicated. In addition to their salaries, they are given remuneration based on the number of posts they create and the influence those posts have.

The CCP’s Cyber Information and Security Committee recruits and trains these web commentators to write and post comments that distract public attention from sensitive events or to create and spread rumors that influence public opinion in ways beneficial to the CCP.

For example, on March 12, 2020, CCP spokesman Zhao Lijian tweeted that “perhaps the U.S. military brought the pandemic to China.” Shortly afterward, web commentators in China began circulating many articles on Chinese social media supporting the argument of that tweet; this led many Chinese to believe that the coronavirus originated in the United States, not in China.

Recently, Ryan Fedasiuk, a researcher at Georgetown University’s Center for Security and Emerging Technology, revealed that China has a Youth Web Army made up of some 20 million volunteers. Indoctrinated by CCP propaganda, these young volunteers actively post many pro-CCP comments and articles online; they believe that what they do is good for their country and for the Chinese people. Given the flood of fake posts on the web in China, it is hard to know which opinions truly represent the voice of the Chinese people and which are just noise.

IV – C. The CCP’s “Health Code App,” a High-Tech Tool

In the wake of the COVID pandemic, the CCP developed a “Health Code” smartphone app, which is mandatory to install on mobile phones. Used for tracking COVID-19 cases, this app displays one of three colors indicating the COVID exposure status of the phone’s owner. When the app screen is yellow or red, the phone holder is prohibited from entering premises, let alone taking flights, trains, buses or taxis. (For more details on the Health Code, see the first part of this series).

Apparently, the authorities use high-tech algorithms and big data, including mobile phone location tracking and automatic contact tracing, to set the Health Code app color of each individual. However, since the authorities can control the color of the app, in practice this means that people’s health codes can be changed for punitive reasons.

The CCP used the Health Code app to abuse human rights lawyers, political dissidents and others it dislikes. For example, lawyer Xie Yang, from the city of Changsha, Hunan province, was a friend of Zhang Zhan. Zhang Zhan was detained for going to Wuhan to report on the real situation during the Wuhan lockdown (see more details in section V – B). Mr. Xie planned to fly to Shanghai on November 5, 2021, to visit Zhang’s mother. He bought a plane ticket online, but very soon two police officers visited him and asked him to cancel the trip. Mr. Xie refused. The next morning, he found that his Health Code had suddenly changed from green to red at 5:29 a.m., which prevented him from taking the 7:55 a.m. flight. Mr. Xie had not left Changsha, and there had been no COVID cases in Changsha for some time. The only logical explanation for his Health Code turning red was that the authorities manually used it to prevent him from going to Shanghai.

On January 4, 2022, the Xi’an government changed the rules of the Health Code app: instead of using yellow to indicate that a person was possibly exposed to a COVID patient, the government set the code to yellow for those who had not taken a COVID PCR test. The government of Zhengzhou, in Henan province, followed suit. In a video speech, an official said that if a citizen skipped two PCR tests, they would get a red color on their Health Code app and be taken away, facing harsh punishment.

V. How Has the CCP Achieved “Zero-COVID Success”?

Did the CCP really achieve great success in implementing its “Zero-COVID” strategy? The answer has two parts.

On the one hand, the CCP’s fierce lockdown may have worked in some cities when there were only a small number of COVID cases; in such circumstances, locking down an entire community could stop the spread. However, after COVID became widespread, locking down an entire city and forcing many people, both infected and uninfected, to quarantine in the same facilities could increase the chance that the uninfected would become infected.

This increased possibility of exposure does not bother the CCP, since it does not care about humanitarian issues such as the life or death of its people; its main concern is its hold on power and its prolonged rule over China. As long as the virus is contained in a given city and does not spread to neighboring regions, the CCP does not care how many people in that city die. It may even consider the death toll worth it.

The CCP’s lockdown approach was like amputating a limb when there was only a sore, even though most of the limb is still healthy.

On the other hand, the CCP greatly underreported infection and death figures, contributing to a rosy illusion in 2020 and 2021 that China won the battle against COVID “under the party’s leadership” while no other country did. However, in 2022, many countries have returned to normal thanks to vaccination and herd immunity, but China is still struggling with its fierce lockdown.

The CCP’s handling of the Wuhan and Xi’an lockdowns showed us its true “Zero-COVID” work.

V – A. Undervaluation of COVID Data

The CCP’s first lockdown of Wuhan lasted from January 23 to April 8, 2020. Official data published on Tencent.com claimed that 50,333 people were infected and 3,869 died during the 76 days of lockdown.

Netizens pointed out that the CCP’s data could not be real; the mortality rates showed a perfect mathematical pattern: between January 22 and 24, the death rate hovered at exactly 3.1% of the total infection count, and then dropped to almost exactly 2.1% over the five days between January 30 and February 3. Netizens joked that “the virus must be good at math.” In fact, all of Wuhan’s hospitals were in great chaos until Beijing sent 6,200 volunteer doctors and nurses from 13 provinces on February 8. How could the death rate have dropped from 3.1% to 2.1%, following a perfect mathematical pattern, during a time when hospitals were out of control?

Some accidentally published figures revealed the real numbers. Tencent.com and NetEase.com showed that by January 26, 2020, China already had 15,701 infection cases and 2,577 deaths, indicating 16.4% deaths among reported infections.

On February 1, 2020, another series of statistics appeared on Tencent.com: up to midnight of that date there were a total of 154,023 COVID cases and 24,589 resulting deaths. The leaked data painted a picture of an infection rate about 10 times higher than that reported by the authorities, as well as a death count 80 times higher and a mortality rate 16 times higher. These leaked data were much more consistent with the figures estimated by many experts. Although the CCP quickly deleted those figures and denied their validity, many people considered them more reliable.

On January 2, 2022, Forbes published two articles claiming that, according to one economist’s model, China’s overall COVID-19 death rate must have been about 170 times higher than the figures reported by the CCP. The article also noted that the CCP intentionally under-reported mortality in order to re-present itself as the “unequivocal leader in the global fight against the virus.” {6}

V – B. Citizen Journalists Reveal the Real Pandemic Situation in Wuhan

Despite the CCP’s great efforts to hide information about the pandemic, citizens spontaneously posted a large number of short news articles, photos, videos, comments and other types of content on WeChat, Weibo and other social media. Four volunteers acting as news reporters, and therefore called “citizen journalists,” posted many documentary reports online, including on foreign platforms such as YouTube, Facebook, Twitter, etc. These citizen journalists were soon detained, as their reports opposed the CCP’s agenda.

  • The first citizen journalist to report on the Wuhan pandemic was Mr. Fang Bin. On January 24, 2020, he told Voice of America that the number of infected people in Wuhan was incalculable. A few days later, on February 1, he visited at least five hospitals and found that many infected patients had died before being tested for COVID, which caused them to be excluded from the official COVID death count. At Wuhan Hospital No. 5, he recorded a video showing eight corpses taken out of the hospital in five minutes and two other body bags abandoned in the hospital. Fang posted his video on YouTube, which prompted a police visit that same night. They confiscated his cell phone and laptop and took him to a police station. Because of public pressure, the police released him shortly afterward. Mr. Fang continued to report his findings every day from February 4 until February 10, when police broke into his home and detained him again. His family has not seen him or received any official legal documents since the detention.
  • Chen Shiqiu was a lawyer who became a citizen journalist. On January 24, 2020, the eve of the Chinese New Year, Chen went to Wuhan to document the emerging pandemic. He received many warning phone calls from the police and was finally taken away by a security team on February 6. After being imprisoned without trial for almost 20 months, he reappeared in public on September 30, 2021. He was ordered not to mention his case in public.
  • Li Zehua was another citizen journalist who went to Wuhan in the early days of the pandemic. He resigned from his post as a CCTV news anchor so that he could cover and report on events without having to follow the CCP’s rules. Li visited funeral facilities and some Wuhan communities, and even tried to investigate the Wuhan Institute of Virology. What he did terrified the CCP; the authorities quickly arrested him on February 26, 2020.
  • Ms. Zhang Zhan was another citizen journalist who had also previously been a lawyer. She went to Wuhan on February 1, 2020, and made numerous posts on Twitter and YouTube about what she saw in hospitals and funeral facilities, as well as what she learned about the Wuhan Institute of Virology. She was arrested on May 14, 2020, and sentenced to four years in prison on November 22, 2020.
  • In a work called “Wuhan Diary,” a Chinese writer named Fang Fang recounted her personal experiences during the lockdown. Since the CCP did not allow the Chinese version to be published in China, Fang Fang published her diary in English. Members of the “50 Cent Party” and the Youth Net Army vehemently denounced her, saying she had “belittled China.” These web commentators did not realize that Fang Fang was trying to help the Chinese people whom the CCP chose to sacrifice and who were not given a chance to speak.

These citizen journalists, along with many others, exposed tragic scenes caused in Wuhan by the COVID virus and the CCP’s lockdown:

  • In a residential community, workers nailed wooden boards over apartment doors to prevent the people inside from leaving.
  • In a hospital, body bags lined the corridors, waiting to be taken to funeral facilities.
  • Armed police guarded makeshift hospitals, making sure the death toll remained secret.
  • At another hospital, two people in hazmat medical suits threw body bags into a van; inside the van, suitcases were piled up.
  • A news item circulated on social media saying Wuhan was running short of body bags; another said support teams had brought mobile incinerators to Wuhan.
  • At a funeral facility, a worker said she and her colleagues had been working continuously to cremate bodies, barely having time to sleep for several days.
  • On WeChat, some locked-down residents asked others to help their relatives who were patients in local hospitals; these residents could not leave their homes, let alone visit a hospital.
  • On Facebook, there is a long list of names under the heading “Those who are not registered”: those who died of COVID-19 but were not included in any official count.

VI – Xi’an’s Dynamic “Zero-COVID” Practice

During a COVID outbreak in December 2021, the city of Xi’an announced its goal of reaching zero COVID cases by January 4, 2022. The authorities devised a “creative” way to meet this goal: all residents of communities with COVID cases would “voluntarily” take buses to quarantine facilities outside the city. After moving these “problem people” out, the city announced a zero COVID count in the city. {7}

Other cities followed Xi’an’s example. For example, on January 15, 2022, the city of Tianjin transported all residents of communities with COVID cases to a quarantine center outside the city, thus achieving its zero-COVID goal.

This became a numbers game. After Shanghai suffered a sharp rise in COVID cases in March this year, it prepared a number of buses to move people, both infected and uninfected from the same community, out of the city to quarantine facilities or makeshift hospitals. Being outside the city, those people were excluded from the city’s infection count. The authorities did not worry about how they were doing or whether they were at high risk of infection by sitting on buses next to other people. Since these facilities were set up outside the city, they might even have lacked some basic services, such as Internet access. This meant that the people there could not complain or post on the web about their living conditions or any mistreatment. Some facilities lacked medical equipment or services, which could lead to deaths or even mass deaths; for this reason, some people call such facilities “concentration camps.”

VI. “The Great Cooperation of the Whole Society”

In July 2020, Dr. Zhang Wenhong, a medical expert and leader in Shanghai’s anti-COVID task force, said that the CCP’s “zero-COVID” policy is based on two of China’s unique characteristics: “strong community management capacity” and “great cooperation of the whole society.”

In Part I of this series, we analyzed in great detail the CCP’s “strong community management capacity.” Let us now examine the notion of “great cooperation of the whole society.” We will focus on the origin of this cooperation: what motivates the Chinese people to cooperate with the CCP?

VI – A. The Result of Brainwashing

Since the CCP took over China in 1949, it has used propaganda to instill in the Chinese population the feeling that the CCP liberated the Chinese people. All Chinese were taught to sing the song “Without the CCP, There Is No New China,” and the CCP painted itself as their savior. It pushed a false logical equivalence between “loving China” and “loving the CCP.”

As a result of this brainwashing, the Chinese people cooperate with the CCP’s orders, even though some have different opinions. The Chinese people were made to believe that being a patriot means being loyal to the CCP and that a person who does not follow the CCP’s orders is a traitor against China.

Chinese youth are even more deeply poisoned, as they grow up under the influence of a propaganda machine that matured over time. At home, their parents cannot teach them traditional Chinese values, as they too were steeped in CCP culture.

The CCP’s long practice of violating human rights makes people disregard the rights of others and their own. During the pandemic, public opinion followed the authorities’ narrative: It is fine to lock up the minority (high-risk individuals) to protect the majority. No matter how badly the minority is treated, as long as this practice brings safety to the majority, the sacrifice is worth it. This amputation approach may sound good at first, but once more people became the minority to be amputated, they began to realize how they were being deprived of basic rights and how the “sacrifice” theory legitimized the CCP to mess with anyone it wanted and destroy them. By then it was too late. They were locked in and suffered the consequences of total isolation, insufficient food and lack of medical treatment.

VI – B. Volunteers Turned Thugs

During the lockdowns, many residents volunteered to support their city’s pandemic response efforts. Some people signed up as volunteers in the hope of securing better conditions for themselves and earning political points during the lockdown. Volunteers were generally allowed to take part in activities outside their homes and exercise a certain degree of power; for most civilians, the alternative would be staying home for the duration of the lockdown. The relative increase in freedom that volunteering offered was tempting for many.

A recording of a phone conversation revealed that a woman was locked in at the home of a man she was visiting. There was no one else at home and the man did not want to host the woman for a prolonged period, so he called the community office for help. The advice he received was that the woman should work as a volunteer so that she could leave his house and return to her own.

The CCP’s long-standing brainwashing efforts made the volunteers feel little sympathy for the locked-down civilians. Some volunteers oppressed, bullied or even beat residents. Below are several examples of volunteers mistreating residents during the city lockdowns:

  • The day after the start of the Xi’an lockdown, in late December 2021, five volunteers beat a person at a PCR testing site over a minor disagreement. The volunteers tried to coerce residents into PCR testing by loudly banging on doorbells door to door.
  • In early January 2022, a young man escaped from his locked-down community in Xi’an to buy food, as he had not stored enough supplies at home when the lockdown suddenly began. Volunteers caught him at the community gate as he returned with several steamed buns; they beat him and threw his food on the ground. {8} Shortly afterward, a resident escaped from another community to buy food and was also caught by the volunteers of the Xi’an community. Instead of physically beating him, they prepared a public humiliation for the man: they revealed his name and address to the public and forced him to read a confession, then broadcast the confession to the community and posted it online. {9}

VI – C. Forced “Cooperation”

The CCP regime forced so-called “cooperation” in both society and cyberspace; the CCP invested significant resources and manpower to control what happens in China. As announced at a press conference organized by the Shaanxi provincial government on December 31, 2021, the city of Xi’an sent 29,000 police officers to help with pandemic control, including 20,352 on community control, 3,709 at checkpoints and patrols, 1,095 on hotel quarantine management, 3,296 on traffic control and 894 at PCR testing sites.

Interestingly, the press conference also mentioned 260 administrative cases, which are lawsuits or complaints filed by citizens against the violation of their rights by the authorities.

Finally, the Xi’an announcement also said that 188 negative news articles published on the web were deleted, and that 70 people who published those articles were located and held accountable. Only “positive news” supporting the CCP’s policies and positions was kept online. Even though many people disagree with the CCP, they are forced to remain silent. In this way, the CCP produced a “total cooperation” for the public to see.

VII. What Can We Learn From the CCP’s “Zero-COVID” Strategy?

After the initial COVID wave in 2020, China was able to resume factory production before other major countries; the CCP attributed this “success” to the “advantage of the communist system.” Being the first major country to return to normal in 2020 allowed Beijing to pick up more orders from the world, reaching record global exports and a record trade surplus against the United States. Some CCP spokespeople said that “the great party led the people to win the battle against COVID.”

However, what helped the CCP maintain a low COVID count in the past was not its “system advantage,” but its inhumane nature. Using its various mechanisms of control over the people, it built COVID concentration camps for the Chinese people, something no democratic country would do. The CCP’s “success” is at the cost of people’s lives and the deprivation of their human rights.

Second, the CCP’s brutal approach can fail when faced with an extremely contagious virus; Shanghai was defeated by the Omicron variant of COVID. The CCP resorted to covering up infection figures and death counts to save face before the Chinese people and the international community.

Third, the CCP introduced the Health Code app, a tool for tracking people’s health status. Since the government can arbitrarily adjust a person’s Health Code, the app can be used to control people’s movements. This app’s ability to conceal information allows the authorities to freeze people at any time and place, for example by imposing travel restrictions on political dissidents or anyone they dislike.

Fourth, the CCP can use “COVID prevention” as an excuse to impose lockdowns and relocations, for example by imposing harsh persecution on the Uyghurs in Xinjiang, if it wishes.

Finally, the CCP created and put into practice several population control mechanisms. In this way, mass protests are stifled and the Chinese people are forced to “cooperate.” During this COVID-19 period, the Chinese people were conditioned to be obedient, and the CCP carried out many practice sessions in cities across China.

This article was originally published in China Scope on May 15, 2022.

Author: Huai Ning (怀宁)

Artículo previo
China Risk: Multinational Companies Face a Crisis of Confidence
Siguiente artículo
The True Face of the Confucius Institute

Artículos Relacionados

No results found.
No results found.