The U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission (USCC) recently warned that China’s interest in U.S. agriculture poses a serious economic challenge and a security risk to the United States.
China holds between 7% and 9% of the world’s arable land, equivalent to 294 million acres, but is home to nearly 20% (1.4 billion in 2020) of the world’s population (nearly 8 billion in 2022). By comparison, the U.S. has more than 375 million acres of arable land and a population of 329.5 million.
China has tried to resolve its dilemma of achieving food security by buying farmland and agricultural companies abroad on a large scale, including in the United States, and has tried to advance its own agricultural technology by stealing American agricultural technology.
“However, the Chinese government’s domestic efforts are not sufficient to solve China’s problems,” the USCC report noted.
“Recognizing its challenges, China has also gone abroad to address its needs through investments and acquisitions of farmland, livestock, agricultural equipment and intellectual property (IP), in particular of transgenic [genetically modified] seeds. The United States is a global leader in all these fields, which has made it a primary trading partner and often a target of China’s efforts to strengthen its agricultural sector and food security, sometimes by illicit means. These efforts have presented several risks to U.S. economic and national security. The acquisition of U.S. hog herds by Chinese companies may save China money and improve its domestic capacity; however, this could also reduce China’s need for U.S.-origin production and redistribute the environmental effects of pig waste to American communities. If further Chinese consolidation and investment in U.S. agricultural assets takes place, China may have undue influence over U.S. supply chains. China’s access to U.S. agricultural IP may also erode U.S. competitiveness in the agricultural technology that supports food production. In addition, China’s illicit acquisitions of genetically modified seeds have provided a boost to China’s development of such seeds, deprived U.S. companies of revenue and offered the opportunity to discover vulnerabilities in U.S. crops.”
The more American agricultural technology China acquires, especially through theft, to become dominant in the field of agrotechnology, the worse the United States will do in selling its own technology, whether to China or to third countries. One of the areas of focus of the ‘Made in China 2025’ plan to become a world leader in high-tech technology and manufacturing is agricultural machinery, such as high-end tractors and combine harvesters. The specific goal is for China to be able to meet 95% of its demand for agricultural machinery with domestically made equipment. According to the USCC report, those policies, supported in part by technology theft, negatively affected U.S. exports of agricultural equipment to China.
“In 2013, U.S. agricultural equipment shipped to China amounted to nearly $27 million,” the USCC found.
“In 2015, the year the Made in China 2025 policy was introduced, exports were around $16 million and have since fallen to about $9 million in 2021.” This has serious implications for U.S. competitiveness, especially because it may also affect U.S. exports to third countries, which may now prefer to buy their agricultural equipment at a lower price in China, where labor costs are minimal.
China expanded its ownership of U.S. land over the last decade, going from 13,720 acres in 2010 to 352,140 in 2020, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA). China’s largest purchase in the U.S. agricultural sector so far was that of Smithfield Foods in 2013, the largest pork producer in the United States. WH Group of China, a company that began as a meat-packing business in China, is its owner today. At the time of the sale, Smithfield had 25 plants in the U.S., 460 farms and contracts with 2,100 producers in 12 states, and Smithfield’s ownership represented more than 146,000 acres of land in the U.S.
The 352,140 acres China owns in the U.S., 192,000 of them agricultural and the rest “other” land, are a small amount compared with the amount of land that countries such as Canada and the Netherlands own in the United States. Canada, for example, owns 4.7 million acres, while the Netherlands owns 4.6 million. However, Canada and the Netherlands do not pose a threat to the U.S. nor do they try to dominate the world.
“The trend is what is most worrying about the nearly 200,000 acres,” Representative Dan Newhouse (R-Wash.) said.
“At first, you look at China’s acreage here and think it is small, but almost all of it was acquired in the last decade. You also have to combine the acreage with the fact that the CCP’s stated goal is to remake the world according to its benefit. The trend is that they keep buying our assets and this has to stop before it becomes an even bigger problem.”
The Chinese did not stop at land, but expanded their operations to include livestock and grain.
“Chinese scientists in some cases chose to simply steal U.S. agricultural technology and intellectual property rather than try to research and develop them themselves,” the USCC noted.
“The acquisition of U.S. trade secrets through agricultural espionage has become a convenient way for China to improve its agricultural production and be more competitive in global markets. China’s transgenic crop research, including seed improvement, is still underdeveloped compared with the United States, which is the largest exporter of transgenic crops. China’s growing transgenic crop industry would benefit greatly from access to protected U.S. seed lines, whose development requires many years and resources. The theft of agricultural intellectual property could allow Chinese agribusinesses to undercut U.S. competitors in international seed markets.”
The USCC estimates that each inbred seed “can cost between $30 and $40 million in laboratory costs, fieldwork and trial and error.”
A famous case of seed theft was successfully prosecuted by the FBI against Mo Hailong, a Chinese national who was sent to the U.S. by Dabeinong Technology Group (DBN), a company that makes feed products and is closely linked to the Chinese government. In the U.S., he collected thousands of inbred corn seeds from fields in Iowa and elsewhere owned by Monsanto and DuPont Pioneer, and then sent them to China. As part of his operations, Hailong also bought two farms in Iowa and Illinois. He was later sentenced to three years in prison and fined.
“Mo Hailong stole valuable proprietary information in the form of corn seeds from DuPont Pioneer and Monsanto in an effort to transport such trade secrets to China,” U.S. Attorney Kevin E. VanderSchel said at the time.
“The theft of trade secrets was a serious federal crime, as it harmed the victim companies that invested millions of dollars and years of work in developing proprietary technology. The theft of agricultural trade secrets, and other intellectual property, posed a serious threat to our national economic security.”
In a more recent case, in April 2022, Xiang Haitao, a Chinese national, was sentenced to 29 months in prison, three years of supervised release and a $150,000 fine, after working as a scientist at the agricultural biotechnology company Monsanto for nearly a decade. He was found guilty of attempting to steal a valuable agriculture-related algorithm from the company and of attempting to take it to China to help accelerate the Chinese government’s technological advances.
“The Chinese government does not hesitate to go after the ingenuity that drives our economy,” FBI Counterintelligence Division Assistant Director Alan E. Kohler Jr. said.
“The theft of our valued technology could lead to the loss of good-paying jobs here in the United States, affecting families and sometimes entire communities. Our economic security is essential to our national security. That is why, at the FBI, protecting our nation’s innovation is both a law enforcement and a national security priority.”
China has also advanced in improving the genetics of its livestock simply by buying American animals. “China purchased millions of American animals as breeding stock, saving itself decades of time and resources in advanced agricultural research devoted to improving the health and nutritional quality of animals,” the USCC noted.
However, the theft of agricultural intellectual property could have not only significant negative economic consequences, but also possible military implications in the form of biological warfare. “While China’s main interest in obtaining transgenic seeds from the United States is to improve its crop yields, it is possible that agricultural IP could be weaponized,” the USCC warned.
“Similar to hacking a computer code, Beijing could easily hack the code or DNA of American transgenic seeds and carry out biological warfare by creating some kind of pest that could destroy U.S. crops… One of the vulnerabilities of transgenic seeds is their limited genetic variation. Therefore, a virus or fungus designed to kill a transgenic plant could wipe out an entire crop with no genetic variation to mitigate losses. In a natural crop, a variety of DNA traits in the field could mitigate some losses and ensure that some of the plants survive viral or fungal infection. Defensive applications of synthetic biology may also be a motivation behind China’s desire to access advanced U.S. seed lines or other agricultural IP. Perhaps indicating the sentiment among Chinese scientists, Jiang Gaoming, a researcher and professor at the Chinese Academy of Sciences, wrote an article about U.S. biodefense efforts, urging other Chinese scientists to channel their research toward China’s biological defense, commenting: ‘Friends, GMO [genetically modified organism] experts, your wisdom must be directed at the enemy, not at your own.'”
This article was originally published in Gatestone on August 19, 2022.
Author: Judith Bergman














